Total Pageviews

Showing posts with label monopsony. Show all posts
Showing posts with label monopsony. Show all posts

Sunday, 11 November 2018

Monopsony power in action! Tanzania Cashew crisis

Click here to access an article discussing the crisis over cashew farming in Tanzania. About 20 houses have been burnt down in riots by cashew nut farmers and other protesters in southern Tanzania, the local MP has told the BBC.
Faith Mitambo said two buildings at her home in Liwale town had been set alight and that other houses targeted belonged to members of the ruling CCM party.

The trouble began after payouts being made to farmers for their crop were less than the price agreed last year.
Topics of relevance are monopsony power, supply & demand, government intervention. Excellent real world economics. 

Thursday, 20 September 2018

Labour Market Failure - including monopsony power

This video from Geoff is an excellent way to look at why the perfect labour market is only an assumption. It also looks at possible solutions and evaluates government policy. Excellent for any essay you might attempt in this area.

 

Click here to access an excellent article on how monopsonist employers are driving down wages in the US.

Wednesday, 5 September 2018

Y13 Labour Markets




1. Discuss Factors That determine wage differentials in the UK? (30)
2. To what extent are wages determined by Marginal Revenue Product MRP theory ? (30)
3. Discuss the impact on Labour Markets of Net Immigration? (30)
4. Discuss whether Trades Unions actually benefit Members and non Members? (30)
5. Explain reasons for the increased labour Market Flexibility? (30)
6. Discuss policies to Increase labour Market Flexibility? (20)
7. Discuss 3 policies to reduce Inequality in the UK (30)
8. Explain causes of increased relative poverty in the UK (10)
9. Discuss policies that the government can use to Increase Labour Market Participation Rates. (3)
10. Discuss the impact of an increase in income tax on labour markets (30)

Tuesday, 18 April 2017

All Themes: Labour markets - all you need to know

Unemployment and economic inactivity in the UK labour market are falling, but when we disaggregate the market we find that there remain persistent issues including risks of extreme poverty, labour immobility, skills shortages and the issues facing workers in vulnerable jobs perhaps facing a monopsony employer. This short revision video looks at the problems in accurately measuring the marginal revenue product from employing an extra worker. This short revision video looks at a numerical example of the difference between the average and marginal cost of employing extra workers when a business has to raise the average wage to expand their workforce. Monopsony is a labour market structure in which there is a single powerful buyer of a particular type of labour. For example, the main buyer of the labour of doctors and nurses is the NHS or large employers such as Capita, G4S, Amazon and Sports Direct. Trade Unions may use their collective bargaining power and bid for employers to pay a premium wage (or “wage mark-up”) above the normal competitive market wage. However, this might lead to an excess supply of labour and a contraction of total employment. This short revision video takes students through the basic analysis and some core evaluation arguments. A trade union is an organised group of employees who work together to represent and protect the rights of workers, usually by using collective bargaining techniques. This short revision video looks at the key roles of trade unions and the long term trend in union membership in the UK labour market.

Saturday, 15 October 2016

Theme 3: Tesco Vs Unilever (Monopsony Vs Monopoly)

This is a battle between Britain's biggest food retailer and one of the world's largest consumer products manufacturing businesses that has economics teachers salivating!
In what has been dubbed the "Marmite War", Tesco has pulled many Unilever products from their online store over a dispute about raising prices. Products such as Marmite, Ben and Jerry's ice cream, Flora and Persil are no longer available because Unilever is pushing for 10 per cent price rises across the board to cover the rising costs of imports following the depreciation of sterling since June 2016.
A lower pound makes import prices more expensive in £s but Tesco is reluctant to raise their prices because of increasingly fierce competition with discount retailers such as Aldi and Lidl.
Retail profit margins have been squeezed over recent years and Aldi and Lidl have more products supplied under a private label and they source more of their processed foods from within the UK. They concentrate on fewer less well known brands at more competitive prices.
Which business will buckle first? Both Tesco and Unilever have significant market power and the likely outcome will likely be a trade-off between the two corporate giants. Price rises are inevitable when the exchange rate falls by more than 15% but not all of the (anglo-Dutch) Unilever's products sold in the UK are produced in overseas countries. Unilever's profit margins are also quite small. What we are seeing here is a battle for profitability across the supply chain.
Readers will be relieved to hear that I have managed by guarantee enough Marmite to last me for the next ten years by purchasing one jar from my local supermarket.

Wednesday, 27 January 2016

Unit 3: Tesco abusing its market power?

Tesco "knowingly delayed paying money to suppliers in order to improve its own financial position", the supermarket ombudsman has found. 

Click here for article.

Useful when discussing the market power of monopsonies and the effectiveness of regulators.


Thursday, 23 April 2015

Unit 3: Supermarkets investigated by the CMA

Thank you to Luke for this excellent article on supermarkets. The competition regulator is to scrutinise allegations that UK supermarkets have duped shoppers out of hundreds of millions of pounds through misleading pricing tactics.

A classic example of powerful firms exploiting the consumers lack of knowledge (asymmetric information).

Take time to look at what the CMA intends to do about it. It highlights to me one of the evaluative points you can make about regulations....it takes forever! In the meantime, the supermarkets can go on exploiting consumers, or decide not to whilst the investigation is ongoing, therefore avoiding fines, leaving them open to continue exploitation in the future!

The article also highlights the issue of monopsony power in the supermarket industry, with 1400 suppliers facing bankrupcy!


Sunday, 7 December 2014

Unit 3: Monopsony Power

Many thanks to Newsnight for providing the material for a lesson about monopsony power - if nothing else, it makes a change from taking Tesco as the model for this topic. 

On Friday, Newsnight carried a report about Premier Foods, a conglomerate which owns many different grocery brands such as Mr Kipling, Ambrosia, Bisto and Oxo. Their allegation is that Premier Foods has been using its power as a major customer to request payments from its suppliers; if they don't pay up, they are 'delisted' from supplying the company. In other words, monopsony power.

The online report comes with a 5-minute video clip which sets up the topic nicely. Newsnight's Laura Kuenssberg interviews engineer Bob Horsely, who had a contract to supply maintenance services to Ambrosia's factory in Devon. He received a letter from Premier Foods saying that "We are aiming to work with a smaller number of strategic suppliers in the future that can better support and invest in our growth ideas. We will now require you to make an investment payment to support our growth." 

When he queried this, he received another letter: "We are looking to obtain an investment payment from our entire supply base and unfortunately those who do not participate will be nominated for de-list."

Premier Foods has been in financial trouble recently, and says that it is trying to invest in growth; it makes the point that, if it succeeds, that can only be to the benefit of its suppliers. However, there are calls for this case to be referred to the Competition and Markets Authority. 

If a supermarket behaved like this, it would be against The Groceries Code which regulates relationships between supermarkets and their suppliers (....but see below*); however, that code doesn't cover manufacturers like Premier Foods.

The article presents a good opportunity for a class exercise, leading to questions like:

- What form of market failure is demonstrated by this case?

- Can Premier Food's statement that "...our suppliers benefit from opportunities to secure a larger slice of our current business. They also stand to gain as our business grows in the future." be justified?

- Should the Groceries Code be extended to include producers as well as retailers?

- What other actions could governments take to prevent this market failure?

- What are the risks of government failure?

* Supermarkets and Suppliers - back to Tesco

There can be no doubt that in this relationship, the power is in the hands of the supermarkets: according to an online report, Britain’s top ten supermarkets owe about £15billion to suppliers for goods at any one time, giving them leverage to 'negotiate' extra payments.

However, listening to The Report on Radio 4 recently, I was really taken aback by the extent of those pressures, as they were explained by current and ex-suppliers and ex-staff of Tesco.

As much as a third of Tesco's gross profit comes, not from sales of goods and services to customers, but from payments they receive from suppliers. Some of those are called “rebates”, reported here in the FT: "Rebates are payments that Tesco receives from suppliers for hitting a certain level of sales, or for support for promotions. For example, Coca-Cola could offer a percentage discount on 2-litre bottles if 20m of them were sold in a specific period – but it will only pay this rebate if the sales target is hit. 

Tesco’s UK sales volumes have dropped as it loses market share to competitors, so there is a risk that such volume-driven rebate targets could be missed." The report in the FT is a fascinating one, very accessible to students, about the way in which such payments are pre-estimated by the retailers in order to be included in their accounts, and this practice has been largely responsible for the 'black hole' of £250mn in Tesco's accounts.


Rebates are clearly common in the industry, and a report in The Grocer implies that many suppliers see this as 'fair enough' - if Tesco can shift huge numbers of the goods, the suppliers and manufacturers benefit by selling more, producing at closer to full capacity and gaining economies of scale. 

However, there are other payments as well. There are listing or gate fees, in which the supplier pays tens or hundreds of thousands of pounds in order to get their products onto Tesco's shelves, more fees in order to get them displayed at eye level, and more recently, payments demanded in order to avoid having products delisted. 

The radio report carried several instances of small scale suppliers who simply couldn't make such payments, and so lost their contract to supply. As a sales negotiator quoted in The Grocer says, when a buyer says 'give me £4mn or I won't stock your product any more', things are getting desperate. Meanwhile, Groceries Code Adjudicator Christine Tacon has urged suppliers to come forward with “hard evidence” to allow her to investigate alleged breaches of the Code.

Wednesday, 12 March 2014

Unit 3: Horizontal Merger & Monopsony Power: Chiquita & Fyffes

A mega merger is creating the world’s largest banana company - it has been announced that Chiquita of the USA and Dublin-based Fyffes will be merging to form a giant banana distribution company.

The merger takes place against the background of rising global consumption and production of bananas. But there is a significant retail price squeeze as the major supermarkets put pressure on distributors such as Chiquita and Fyffes to absorb increases in wholesale costs. 


Many supermarkets are now buying direct from banana growers. In the UK, fierce supermarket price wars have forced down the price of loose bananas, making them cheaper now than 20 years ago. Many supermarkets use bananas as a loss-leader to attract customers into their stores.

)

The merger is likely to give the horziontally integrated company more negotiating (monopsony) power with suppliers - the new business will distribute over 160 million cases of bananas per year and put it well in front of rivals Del Monte and Dole. In Europe Fyffes has a market share of 16%, the combined European market share will be closer to 30% and their global market share is estimated to be 16%.

The global banana market is an oligopoly - 80% of the world banana market in the hands of only three companies.

Around one third of the bananas sold by Fyffes meet the criteria established by the FairTrade Foundation. Although the bulk of bananas grown in the world are consumed in the country of production, when it comes to banana exports, only 12% of the final retail price stays in the producing countries. 

An even smaller proportion goes to small farmers (5%-7%) or to plantation workers (1%-3%). Few banana growers are able to pay their workers a living wage.

The new company, ChiquitaFyffes, will be worth around $1bn (£600m). It will be listed on the New York Stock Exchange but based in Dublin, Ireland.

)

Tuesday, 1 October 2013

Unit 3: Monopsony Power in Qatar

A deeply troubling report featured here in the Guardian. Qatar, one of the richest countries on the planet, will be hosting the World Cup in 2022. But much of the Gulf state's expansion is being built by some of the poorest migrant workers in the world. In the worst cases, employees are not being paid and work in conditions of forced labour. Thousands of workers from Nepal are trapped in jobs and wages very different to what they were promised.

Thank you Klaus...I have updated the post to include Dubai workers clip as well.




Related Exam questions:

1 In August 2009 the Competition Commission published a Groceries Supply Code of
Practice. Large supermarket chains were paying very low prices to some suppliers.
Which type of market power does this suggest the large supermarket chains have?
(1)

A Monopsony
B Monopolistic competitive
C Perfectly competitive
D Natural monopoly

E Competitive monopoly




Monday, 17 December 2012

Unit 3: Exam Question on Monopsony

The case study here is the UK supermarket industry, probably the best example we've got of a monopsony- with a 4-firm concentration ratio of 76%, and around 7,000 firms supplying food products to the industry.

Click here to access an interesting case study to create the material, and read and attempt the 3 questions in the style of Edexcel's unit 3 exam structure at the end.




P.S. Remember that Edexcel Unit 3 exams would also have an 8-mark question, but I couldn't think of anything else to ask about monopsonies so there's only 3 here!